Our analysts compared BigCommerce vs Adobe Commerce based on data from our 400+ point analysis of eCommerce Platforms, user reviews and our own crowdsourced data from our free software selection platform.
Analyst Rating
User Sentiment
BigCommerce is a powerful SaaS platform for designing and managing multiple eCommerce websites. It centralizes product information and helps you distribute catalogs across marketplaces, social media and business websites. You can manage inventory, orders and shipping from any device and set up unique automation to increase productivity and avoid errors.
What sets it apart is its open and headless architecture, which allows for customization and integration. It offers a storefront editor with customizable themes but doesn’t restrict you from using other editors.
During testing, I could use the platform’s backend for product management, order fulfillment and customer data handling while having complete freedom to design and develop custom storefronts.
Another area in which BigCommerce excels is international commerce. Its support for multiple currencies and integration of global payment methods and shipping options make expanding into new markets a breeze.
The platform's handling of international taxes and duties is also impressive, saving considerable time and effort. Additionally, it charges zero transaction fees, helping control costs for businesses with large sales volumes.
Lastly, BigCommerce helps you remain nimble due to its flexibility. It offers open access to its APIs, SDKs and data without any proprietary blockers or frictions. This allows you to connect the platform to any software and build the perfect tech stack for your evolving needs.
Adobe Commerce is an end-to-end platform for creating digital storefronts, managing catalogs, setting up fulfillment workflows, and personalizing shopper experiences based on location, preferences, and navigation history. It supports all the major eCommerce business models, including B2B, D2C, dropshipping and B2C.
It provides tools for catalog management, inventory control, order processing and customer management. Businesses can efficiently organize their product information, track stock levels, handle orders and maintain detailed customer records. The platform also offers dynamic pricing and promotions, allowing businesses to implement various pricing strategies and create targeted marketing campaigns.
One of its key strengths is the ability to handle complex B2B scenarios. It supports features like multi-tier pricing, customer-specific catalogs and complex approval workflows. Additionally, the platform offers tools for quote management, contract management and purchase order processing, making it suitable for businesses dealing with large-scale transactions and multiple buyers.
The platform also supports personalization and customer experience optimization. It offers data analytics to provide insights into customer behavior, allowing businesses to tailor product recommendations, promotions and content to individual customers. Integration with other Adobe Experience Cloud solutions enables a holistic view of the customer journey, helping deliver consistent experiences across different channels.
among all eCommerce Platforms
BigCommerce has a 'great' User Satisfaction Rating of 86% when considering 1676 user reviews from 5 recognized software review sites.
Adobe Commerce has a 'great' User Satisfaction Rating of 83% when considering 1655 user reviews from 4 recognized software review sites.
SelectHub research analysts have evaluated BigCommerce and concluded it earns best-in-class honors for Integrations.
SelectHub research analysts have evaluated Adobe Commerce and concluded it earns best-in-class honors for Catalog and Product Management, Inventory Management and Order Management.
During testing, I noticed right off the bat that BigCommerce is a feature-rich platform that needs a lot of customization to fit my exact needs. Plus, there aren’t guided onboarding experiences, making implementation time-consuming. You must manually explore the interface to learn how to create or connect a domain, add products, set up fulfillment workflows, connect sales channels and design a storefront.Secondly, what caught my eye was the platform's speed and operability. BigCommerce boasts a 99% website uptime, and I could see why. It automatically optimizes images, minimizes HTTP requests and uses browser cache to identify customers. Also, a global content delivery network allows visitors worldwide to view your site from the nearest server.I loved how intuitive it is to connect and manage sales channels using BigCommerce. You can set up differentiated experiences for each channel using dynamic pricing, multiple product views, product swatches and bulk pricing tools. A robust customer segmentation module automatically groups similar customer personas based on your rules and helps design personalized experiences.The storefront editor uniquely lets you design a carousel for the website header. However, I didn’t like anything else about the storefront editor. It has limited free themes, and paid ones are comparatively more expensive than what competitors offer. That said, the platform's headless architecture helps compensate by enabling custom storefront development.My only point of contention was its unique pricing model. It charges a base subscription fee and puts a cap on your business's annual sales. If you exceed this cap, BigCommerce takes a percentage of your revenue based on your subscription plan.Also, if you connect the platform to a POS, every POS sale is considered an eCommerce sale, leading to a higher sales volume and cost. This leads to complex TCO calculations for enterprises with large sales volumes and international customers.Overall, BigCommerce is one of the best options for growing mid-sized businesses that can offset the platform cost with their sales revenue. It's flexible and can adapt to multiple business models, including B2B, D2C and dropshipping, with separate storefronts for each.However, the platform can be overkill for small businesses and may require significant investments to unlock its full potential. That's because all the good features like multi-storefront, personalization, customer segmentation and headless architecture are available in higher-tier plans. Also, lower-tier plans are comparatively more expensive than those of competitors like Shopify.
Adobe Commerce is a highly sophisticated eCommerce platform that offers a high level of flexibility and customization. Its headless architecture empowers businesses to design unique storefronts tailored to specific audiences and geographies.I found its native PWA studio to be a game-changer during testing, enabling the creation of high-performance mobile experiences. The platform's A/B testing and content staging capabilities are also helpful for optimizing customer engagement and driving conversions.One of Adobe Commerce's standout features is its robust personalization engine. By creating detailed customer personas and leveraging AI-powered pattern recognition, you can deliver highly targeted product recommendations and experiences.However, I found the platform's complexity to be undeniable. Implementing and customizing Adobe Commerce requires significant time and resources. While the vendor offers implementation services, gaining full proficiency with the platform involves a steep learning curve.Despite its high cost, Adobe Commerce is an excellent choice for large enterprises and D2C brands that demand a highly customizable and scalable solution. Its rich feature set can drive significant business growth. However, the platform's limited built-in integrations can be a drawback, requiring additional development efforts to connect with external systems.Overall, Adobe Commerce is a powerful tool for enterprises seeking to create exceptional online shopping experiences for multiple geographies. But, it can be overkill for solo entrepreneurs and medium-sized businesses, and they may find it tough to offset the platform cost with sales revenue.
WE DISTILL IT INTO REAL REQUIREMENTS, COMPARISON REPORTS, PRICE GUIDES and more...