Home > HR Management Software > ADP Vantage HCM > ADP Vantage HCM vs SumTotal

ADP Vantage HCM vs SumTotal

Last Updated:

Our analysts compared ADP Vantage HCM vs SumTotal based on data from our 400+ point analysis of HR Management Software, user reviews and our own crowdsourced data from our free software selection platform.

Overview Pricing Benefits & Features User Ratings Analyst Summary Screenshots
ADP Vantage HCM Software Tool
SumTotal Software Tool
Get Free Demo Demo    Request Pricing Pricing
Get Free Demo Demo    Request Pricing Pricing

Product Basics

ADP Vantage HCM, a cloud-based, on-premise and open architect solution, brings together core human resources services through integrated modules that help manage payroll, time and attendance, workforce management, talent management and more. It helps organizations of all sizes across the U.S. improve employee engagement and gain real-time insights to enhance workforce processes and workplace operations.

It simplifies office administrative operations, minimizes risks, reduces expenses and provides dedicated guidance to enhance operational efficiency. Talent managers can streamline the onboarding process and synchronize performance with preset goals on a monthly and yearly basis. It also offers a mobile application.
read more...
SumTotal is a cloud-based HR Management software catering to mid-sized to large organizations. It packs a comprehensive suite of features covering talent acquisition, learning & development, workforce management, and performance management. Users praise its robust reporting & analytics, rich learning library, and mobile-friendly accessibility. However, the extensive customization options and powerful tools come with a steeper learning curve for administrators. Additionally, SumTotal's potential for high integration costs and higher price point compared to basic solutions make it less suitable for smaller companies. While some users struggle with complex content creation tools and limited instructor-led options, SumTotal shines in its ability to scale and adapt to dynamic needs, making it a strong contender for organizations seeking a feature-rich, customizable HR management platform, especially those with substantial training requirements and a dispersed workforce.

Pros
  • Comprehensive learning library
  • Robust reporting & analytics
  • Scalable for large organizations
  • Mobile-friendly learning
  • Customizable user experience
 Cons
  • Steep learning curve for admins
  • Limited instructor-led options
  • Complex content creation tools
  • Potentially high integration costs
  • Pricey for smaller companies
read more...
$150/User, Monthly
Free Trial is available →
Get a free price quote
Tailored to your specific needs
$5/User, Monthly
Free Trial is unavailable →
Get a free price quote
Tailored to your specific needs
Small 
i
Medium 
i
Large 
i
Small 
i
Medium 
i
Large 
i
Windows
Mac
Linux
Android
Chromebook
Windows
Mac
Linux
Android
Chromebook
Cloud
On-Premise
Mobile
Cloud
On-Premise
Mobile

Product Assistance

Documentation
In Person
Live Online
Videos
Webinars
Documentation
In Person
Live Online
Videos
Webinars
Email
Phone
Chat
FAQ
Forum
Knowledge Base
24/7 Live Support
Email
Phone
Chat
FAQ
Forum
Knowledge Base
24/7 Live Support

Product Insights

  • Improved Organizational Visibility: Senior leaders can compare, uncover and boost employee performance by enabling improved employee visibility. 
  • Compliance Confidence: Get support for crucial compliance programs such as OFCCP, EEOC and the FCRA. Automate procedures to verify forms as well as collect and approve tax credit information for federal taxes. 
  • Enhanced Recruitment Process Outsourcing Efforts: Improve hiring times and the quality of hires. With RPO, leverage public information about prospective hires, which enables identifying the best match for the organization. 
  • Better Focus: Focus on crucial tasks that result in improved organizational efficiency by using numerous scalable and flexible solutions for talent hiring and management. 
  • Quick Decision Making: Receive real-time alerts and notifications that let supervisors make necessary decisions without any delays, anywhere with an internet connection. 
  • Error-Free Payroll Processing: Scale payroll processes as needed and eliminate the chance of errors by integrating payroll with human resource management and automatically syncing employee information. 
read more...
  • Employee Retention: Provide tools for employee development, management and learning practices that encourage employee retention. 
  • Enhanced Productivity: Talent managers can continuously onboarding to speed up overall productivity. 
  • Organizational Stability: Learning-centered employee development builds an agile workforce that is adaptable to changing business environments. 
  • Learning Ecosystem: Invest in research and development on the latest learning trends, which managers can leverage to enhance employees' learning experience. 
  • Talent Engagement: Engage top talent while moving through the recruitment process, understand the workforce, identify the best talent and build a seamless experience for candidates as well as hiring teams. 
  • Enhanced Candidate Experience: Offer smartphone-optimized sites with intelligent and automated interview tools, candidate matching, and an easy-to-use mobile app interface. Keep applicants informed about upcoming interview details via a user dashboard. 
  • Accelerated Time-to-Performance: Seamless onboarding training helps new hires get up to speed quickly. Provide unique company policies and work culture for them to become familiar with the company. 
  • Smooth Role Switch: Access onboarding plans for new roles that include defined goals, new teams and KPI’s that ensure a more seamless transition to new responsibilities. 
  • Robust Manager and Admin Capabilities: Managers and administrators can easily view, schedule, filter, mark up and share reports from a mobile dashboard. Leverage reporting tools, advanced reports and dashboards at a single click. 
  • Informed Compensation Plans: Create smart, data-driven compensation plans according to preset or custom parameters. Real-time performance insights and budget modeling make compensation informed, fair and cost-effective. 
read more...
  • Synchronized Employee Performance: Creates small snippets of ongoing dialogue, providing touchpoints that enable managers to track employee progress against assigned goals. 
  • Proactive Learning: Enables compliance training, employee certification and the skills required for specific positions. Posts, comments and vote functionalities promote an interactive learning experience for users. 
  • Pay-for-Performance: Creates and executes pay-for-performance strategies that help align compensation rewards with individual performance. 
  • Employee Benefits Administration: Employee benefit administration solutions simplify processes, raise employee engagement rates and help maintain the best talent pool possible. 
  • Group Health Insurance Policies: Provides access to ADPIA and its carrier partner’s health insurance benefits. Offers employees a medium to look up advice from experienced and licensed professionals. 
  • Business Insurance: Connect with licensed company insurance agents for instances such as general liability insurance, mandated worker’s compensation and more. 
  • Automated Time Tracking: Save time and effort while enhancing compliance and improving productivity by tracking the shift timings of employees. 
read more...
  • Talent Development: Provides combined functionality of talent onboarding, talent management and learning management solutions to cater to talent development requirements. 
  • Talent Acquisition: Helps create a streamlined hiring cycle, hire the right talent, engage fresh recruits and drive productivity from day one. 
  • Learning Management:  
    •  Helps provide a customized, personalized and engaging learning experience tailored to the skill and competency of individuals rather than the whole team. 
    •  Ease of access on all devices, along with an offline mode, ensures seamless and consistent access to content and courses. 
  • Talent Management: Personalized and intuitive tools help employees pursue career growth and development. Capabilities include performance management, 360-degree feedback, succession planning and compensation management. 
  • Performance Management: Provides comprehensive feedback and tools that make feedback actionable, constructive and insightful. Measures workforce productivity, progress and priorities in real time. 
  • Succession Planning: Enables talent managers to identify and assess skill gaps, build agile talent pools, and align employee success with business goals and objectives. 
  • Compensation Management: Simplifies and streamline compensation plans, and helps build competitive packages to attract and retain top recruits. Workflow automation and compensation management tools aid compliance with complex global policies. 
  • Workforce Management: Bundled payroll, benefits and expense management minimize time, cost and efforts while maximizing accuracy. Features include automated scheduling, time and attendance, absence management, and compliance. 
  • Applicant Tracking System: Includes real-time alerts and notifications for offer approvals, a unique dashboard and reports widgets, customizable requisitions, and a consolidated requisition workspace. 
  • Mobility: Provides access to tools and reporting capabilities at all times and from any location. The dashboard can be operated using a tablet, desktop, mobile app or a phone browser. 
  • Growth Edition: Caters to the needs of fast-growing small and medium-sized businesses. Includes webinars, instructor-led training, approvals, and additional learning resources that users can access and configure anytime. 
  • Extended Enterprise: Helps build a brand image, accelerate growth and drive new sources of potential revenue. Facilitates an enriched and optimized learning experience for distributors, partners and customers. 
  • Gamified and Collaborative Learning: Helps: 
    •  Assess and accelerate learning with gamification capabilities that include leaderboards, points, levels and badges. 
    •  Enhance employee engagement by identifying and rewarding the right learning behaviors. 
    •  Enrich the knowledge of new hires with collaborative learning, up-to-date content, feedback and social ratings. 
read more...

Product Ranking

#20

among all
HR Management Software

#23

among all
HR Management Software

Find out who the leaders are

User Sentiment Summary

Good User Sentiment 592 reviews
Fair User Sentiment 132 reviews
76%
of users recommend this product

ADP Vantage HCM has a 'good' User Satisfaction Rating of 76% when considering 592 user reviews from 5 recognized software review sites.

69%
of users recommend this product

SumTotal has a 'fair' User Satisfaction Rating of 69% when considering 132 user reviews from 4 recognized software review sites.

4.4 (19)
n/a
3.9 (228)
3.2 (39)
n/a
2.7 (7)
3.5 (175)
n/a
4.7 (11)
4.0 (56)
3.8 (159)
2.9 (30)

Synopsis of User Ratings and Reviews

Ease of Access: The fingerprint touch feature provides easy access to several tools anytime and anywhere, according to all users that mention this feature.
Customization: According to 75% of reviews mentioning customization, the software offers a lot of options to suit all business needs.
Comprehensive Tools: All reviewers who reference this element noted that ADP Vantage HCM is an all-in-one solution for HR, payroll, workforce management and employee onboarding
Regular Updates: According to 100% of reviews on this aspect, regular enhancements help improve functionality and fix issues.
Show more
Robust Tools: All reviews on this feature suggest that SumTotal provides a robust set of talent development and management, payroll, and workforce management solutions.
Effective Tracking: According to 80% of reviews on tracking, the software optimizes talent management by tracking development and career growth.
Self-Service: Managers and employees can access and complete training courses at their convenience, according to all reviews on self-service.
Show more
Steep Learning Curve: 80% of reviews on this element suggested that the solution has a steep learning curve for new users, especially for managers.
Incomplete Mobile App: The mobile application lacks several features that are present on the desktop version, as indicated by all reviews mentioning the mobile app.
Unresponsive Customer Service: According to all reviews referencing this aspect, the customer service is slow and doesn’t have a dedicated service representative for clients.
Complicated Navigation: The navigation is clunky and complicated for several features, according to 80% of reviews mentioning navigation.
Show more
Outdated Course Content: About 70% of reviews on course content reported that some modules aren’t frequently updated, resulting in an outdated learning experience.
Non-Intuitive Functions: Most features and functions aren’t intuitive, making it difficult to navigate, according to all reviews on this aspect.
Access to Reports: Accessing and pulling reports is extremely tedious and slow, according to 100% of reviews on reporting.
Customer Service: All reviews on customer support suggest that customer service is very slow and unresponsive.
Show more

ADP Vantage HCM’s cloud-based toolset provides a robust HCM experience, from core HR to payroll to talent management, best-suited for midsize to large companies. Users indicated some of the features are difficult to navigate and that the mobile app lacks some functionality. There’s also a steep learning curve involved for new users. However, it can be a good option for those looking for a system with regular updates, great customization and accessibility.

Show more

SumTotal users paint a mixed picture, praising its robust functionality and mobile accessibility while critiquing its clunky interface and steep learning curve. Many laud its comprehensive suite, encompassing everything from onboarding to performance management, finding it a one-stop shop for HR needs. One user gushes, "It's like having a whole HR department in the cloud!" However, ease of use seems to be a major sticking point. Comments like "The interface feels outdated and unintuitive" and "Learning curve is a mountain, not a hill" pop up frequently. This is often contrasted with praise for competitors like Workday, lauded for its sleek design and user-friendliness. One user sums it up: "SumTotal has the depth, Workday has the polish." Mobile accessibility shines as a bright spot, with users appreciating the ability to manage tasks on the go. This stands out compared to some competitors, making SumTotal a good fit for companies with a mobile workforce. Ultimately, SumTotal seems to be a powerful tool for organizations willing to invest the time and effort in mastering its complexities. As one user puts it, "It's not perfect, but it's incredibly versatile. If you can handle the initial climb, the view from the top is pretty good."

Show more

Screenshots

Top Alternatives in HR Management Software

ADP Workforce Now
BambooHR
Cornerstone OnDemand
Dayforce
Infor HCM
Justworks
Oracle HCM Cloud
Paycom
Paycor
PDS Vista
Rippling
SuccessFactors
Talentsoft
TriNet
UKG Dimensions
UKG Pro
Workable
Workday HCM

Related Categories

Attendance Tracking Software
Benefits Administration Software
Bookkeeper Software
Caregiver Payroll Software
Certified Payroll Software
Construction Payroll Software
Construction Time Tracking Software
Direct Deposit Payroll Software
Employee Feedback Software
Employee Pulse Survey Tools
Farm Payroll Software
HR Case Management Software
HR Software For Nonprofits
HRIS Systems
Human Services Software
Invoicing and Payroll Software
Manufacturing Payroll Software
Onboarding Software
Online HR Software
Payroll Check Printing Software
Payroll Compliance Software
Payroll Software
Payroll Software For Accountants
Payroll Software For Mac
Payroll Software For Schools
Payroll Tax Software
Restaurant Payroll Software
Security Guard Payroll Software
Small Business Payroll Software
Time and Attendance Software
Time Clock Software
Time Tracking Software
Timesheet Software
Trucking Payroll Software
Show more
Applicant Tracking Systems
Assessment Software
Background Check Software
Behavioral Assessment Tools
Benefits Administration Software
Call Center Workforce Management Software
Candidate Relationship Management Software
Certification Tracking Software
College Recruiting Software
Computer Based Training Software
Corporate LMS
Course Creation Software
Deep Learning Software
E-Learning Software
Educational Software
Elearning Authoring Tools
Employee Engagement Software
Employee Feedback Software
Employee Goal Setting Software
Employee Pulse Survey Tools
Employee Retention Software
Enterprise LMS
Healthcare LMS
Hospitality LMS
HR Case Management Software
HR Software For Nonprofits
HRIS Systems
Human Services Software
Interview Scheduling Software
Job Board Software
LMS For Manufacturing
LMS For Nonprofits
LMS For Retail
LMS For Schools
LMS Software
Mobile Workforce Scheduling Software
Onboarding Software
Online Course Platforms
Online HR Software
Online Learning Platforms
Online Training Software
Pre-Employment Assessment Tools
Recruiting CRM Software
Recruitment Software
Social Learning Platforms
Succession Planning Software
Talent Acquisition Software
Talent Intelligence Software
Talent Management Systems
Training Management System Software
Tutoring Software
Video Interview Software
Virtual Classroom Software
Workforce Management Software
Show more

WE DISTILL IT INTO REAL REQUIREMENTS, COMPARISON REPORTS, PRICE GUIDES and more...

SelectHub Products Reporting and Analytics
Build Your Requirements
SelectHub Products Cost and Pricing Guide
Get Your Free Comparison Report
Compare products
Comparison Report
Just drag this link to the bookmark bar.
?
    Table settings